Tag Archives: Attorney

What are the Trade-offs of Becoming a Company Principal? Four Points

Situation: A senior employee is on a good growth track within her company. The CEO has stated that he believes that she has the potential to become a principal of the company in the future. What are the tradeoffs of becoming a company principal?
Advice from the CEOs:
• Becoming a principal involves both greater potential rewards than being an employee and greater potential risks. Create a chart with two columns. In one, list the potential rewards of having a stake in the company. In the other list the costs and potential liabilities. This will help to weigh the rewards against the liabilities.
• Areas to negotiate include voting rights, granting of options, understanding the perks of becoming a partner, and also the possibility of legal liability for any malfeasance that the company may commit.
• If you see liabilities that concern you talk to an attorney – your own, not the company’s – about how to address these liabilities in the terms of an employment contract as a principal.
• Evaluate the potential long term value of the ownership share being offered. Does the company have a buy-back policy for a principal’s ownership share and, if so, what are the terms?

[like]

What Do You Gain by Buying Out a Co-founder? Six Points

Situation: A CEO founded his company with a long-term friend. For several years, this co-founder has contributed little and has proven to be difficult with key employees. In an important sense, the co-founder has become a distraction. A challenge is that the co-founder is a significant shareholder. What do you gain by buying out a co-founder?

Advice from the CEOs:

  • First and foremost – peace of mind. While the CEO and his allies control a majority of shares there is no guarantee that this remains the case. Long-term it can cause headaches to have a large block of shares in the hands of someone who could be hostile. The challenge is gaining control of a solid majority of shares at a reasonable price.
  • How is the value of the co-founder’s shares determined?
    • In most minority interest situations, minority interest is discounted because it is of limited value to a non-company purchaser. While it may be necessary to pay a premium to gain controlling interest in the company, this will be a premium over the discounted minority interest value, not over the fair value for all shares.
  • There are two aspects to a purchase: price and terms. It is acceptable to accept the co-founder’s price, but insist on favorable terms, e.g., 10 years to pay at 5% interest.
    • Set the terms so that the company guarantees the payment, not the CEO personally.
  • At this point the co-founder is a disruptive force within the company. Act now before more damage is done.
    • As to order of business, take action with respect to the co-founder first, then negotiate the purchase of his shares after he is no longer an employee.
    • Be sure to communicate the decision effectively to the other employees. Speak to the long-term strategic value of the company, the CEO’s vision for the company, and a determination to build the company into a viable entity with a range of customers and growth opportunities for the team.
  • Important steps as you move forward:
    • Have a plan.
    • Speak to an attorney – the company should pay but this is the CEO’s attorney, not the company’s attorney. Assure that as CEO you limit personal exposure and do things appropriately.
    • Assure that the employees understand and support this action and that they clearly understand the plan going forward.
    • Offer the co-founder a more generous severance package than would ordinarily be considered prudent.
    • Fire the co-founder as soon as plans are in place and announce a Board Meeting 30 days hence to discuss the management restructuring.
  • As a final note, this is one of the most difficult things that must be done by a CEO. The co-founder has been a long-term friend. Nothing about this is easy. It is likely to get more painful before it gets better. In the long run, however, this can be better for both individuals. Work toward that objective.

[like]