Which is Preferable C or S-Corp Status? Six Suggestions

Situation: A company’s accountant advises them to transition from a C Corporation to an S Corporation. Remaining a C Corp would force them into accrual accounting with significant tax consequences. The accountant also advises that it is easier to sell an S Corp to a buyer, and S Corp status would relieve problems with retained earnings. Which do you think is preferable, C or S Corp status?

Advice from the CEOs:

  • Accountants disagree. Get a second opinion. Also consult a tax or corporate lawyer who will provide another perspective.
  • Another company looked at S vs. C status and found two key factors:
    • S Corp status is great if you expect to lose money for a few years because of the benefit that it can offer to personal taxes. Over the long-term you should look at the difference between personal and corporate tax rates and set your strategy so that it makes the most sense.
    • An S Corp cannot have non-U.S. shareholders.
  • There is more flexibility with C Corp status in your ability to grant options, sell shares, etc. For a suitor, purchase of C Corp shares prior to a full acquisition is like a date before deciding on marriage.
  • C Corp status is good if you are building an empire. S Corp status is better if want to have employee ownership under an ESOP as an option for exit.
  • Since taxes are a significant part of this decision, think carefully before you shift from cash accounting.
    • Once you commit to accrual accounting you can’t go back to cash basis.
    • To the extent have an accrued tax liability you can extend payment of this liability over multiple years.
  • You also may want to consider a hybrid accounting method:
    • Accrual for sales
    • Cash for service
    • Look at whether there are tax advantages to a hybrid model.

2 thoughts on “Which is Preferable C or S-Corp Status? Six Suggestions

  1. Michael Mort

    Let the age and size determine the decision. When starting out, you MUST be an LLC, taxed as a partnership. It’s easiest and most flexible. As you add partners (investors) convert to being taxed as S-Corp, still governed as an LLC. Usually around 3-5 partners. Sometime well before you hit the limit of 100 partners in an S-Corp it will be obvious that C-Corp status is needed, usually because investors demand the formalities and restrictions of multiple classes of ownership (common and preferred shares). Then convert from LLC to C-Corp for both governance and taxes.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Sign in with Twitter